Just getting around to a lot of these comments, sorry. I have been far, far away from computers and screens.
Termi, you don't make much of convincing case, to me, at least, by citing industry awards. (I'm a film critic who thinks the Oscars are useless, a pageant for the liberal wing of the 1%.)
Citing consensus opinion regarding Uncharted, The Walking Dead and The Dark Knight (all overblown and overrated titles, IMO) doesn't do much to move me either. I am aware that just consulting the awards listings and aggregators like the Tomatometer settles it for a lot of folks, though.
Citing the stated intentions of a game's creators carries a little weight, sure, but never more than the evidence of the work itself, or, in this case, the way the work was sold to an apparently bloodthirsty audience. And you might have missed it, but we do get to see the spray of blood and bone before the cut to the title card.
See my followup article and my comment under it to get a little more of where I'm coming from. Or try to peek over somebody's shoulder if you're worried about giving me more clicks. So long as you actually read it, brother.
Posted on July 9th, 2012 12:32am