Watch as Andrew Cuomo makes the State Senate into a no-lose proposition

watch-andrew-cuomo-makes-state-senate-no-lose-proposition

Andrew Cuomo and legislative leaders. Governor Andrew Cuomo, via flickr

11:45 am Dec. 5, 2012

Someone from Cuomoland contacted me this morning with a complaint about the subject line in my morning email newsletter, which referred to a "Cuomo coalition" now running the State Senate.

Shortly afterward, Cuomo released an op-ed to the Albany Times Union endorsing the coalition, which he presents as the best oppotunity for a functional Senate.

Cuomo talks in the piece about how Democrats "squandered the opportunity" when they ran the State Senate, and says that "The Democratic Conference dysfunction was legendary and the current leadership has failed" to keep some members from defecting.

Cuomo, the governor and functional leader of the New York State Democratic Party, went on to say that "rather than base my support on amorphous and often misleading political labels" he'll wait to see how this new coalition works before supporting or opposing it.

It's a characteristically deft political play.

For one thing, Cuomo is making the endorsement of the deal between Jeff Klein's breakaway Democrats and Dean Skelos' Republicans conditional, so he can take credit for the coalition arrangement if it's seen to be working and abandon it if the arrangement breaks down or otherwise becomes unseemly in the eyes of the voting public.

For another, Cuomo is taking the opportunity to make explicit his expectation that the Senate will work to implement his agenda, which he presents here as a "litmus test" that reads as broadly progressive but divergent from the union position on taxes and education reform. A present and future campaign platform, essentially:

Specifically, the “litmus test” for my support starts with support of the following ten issues:

1. The property tax cap that has finally imposed fiscal discipline on local governments and provided relief to taxpayers

2. Campaign finance reform

3. Increasing the minimum wage

4. Reform of New York City’s “stop and frisk” policy

5. Environmental protection and initiatives that address our changing climate

6. The education and Medicaid budget rate formulas that provided fiscal predictability and sustainability

7. The tax cuts that brought taxes on the middle class tax to the lowest rates in 58 years

8. Education reforms – like teacher evaluations – that bring more accountability to our schools and continued improvement to our SUNY system

9. Protecting a woman’s right to choose

10. Limited and highly regulated casinos introduced as economic development generators

And, preemptively addressing one of the great potential problems with this posture—Cuomo is a loyal Democrat who thinks his party is useful and great except when doesn't—the governor essentially makes his position on the Senate a carve-out, applicable in this instance because of the close division between the parties in the chamber and in particular because of the poor track record of the Democratic conference in the past.

Cuomo writes: "With margins this close, I expect the leadership situation to be fluid and subject to influence for some time. I can offer the people of the state my opinion at any time over the next two years, when practice has provided clarity."

So Cuomo does own this Senate coalition, politically. And he will continue to own it right up until the moment he decides not to.

Comments (3)
BarbaraR wrote on December 5, 2012, 8:16 PM [Link]

These "independent" Democrats should be recalled. If we had wanted to elect Republicans, we would have voted them in. These are turncoats and betrayers of the public trust as our representatives.
Cuomo surely is overjoyed now because any progressive efforts put forth by the regular Dems will now be curtailed at no cost to him as there is a Republican Senate majority.

Don't worry, Andrew, we the public are not stupid, and will remember how you prefer power over service to the people.

BarbaraR wrote on December 5, 2012, 8:17 PM [Link]

These "independent" Democrats should be recalled. If we had wanted to elect Republicans, we would have voted them in. These are turncoats and betrayers of the public trust as our representatives.
Cuomo surely is overjoyed now because any progressive efforts put forth by the regular Dems will now be curtailed at no cost to him as there is a Republican Senate majority.

Don't worry, Andrew, we the public are not stupid, and will remember how you prefer power over service to the people.

Middle Class Mike wrote on December 6, 2012, 1:59 AM [Link]

Gov. Cuomo is being too clever by half:

this guy is going to be sunk on character traits over time, because they seem to portray this about his inner life to me. He tends to think you can sell the public anything, if you package it with slick enough wrapping paper. Mr. Cuomo likes to see himself as a champion of the disempowered, but paradoxically has now disempowered the Democratic electorate he supposedly represented. Our Governor likes to be portrayed as a nice fellow, but his body language over time screams, "back off I'm talking now" and sooner or later that's going to cost him.

His actions on the 'Coalition' arrangement in the Senate seem to reflect that he quietly backed it, and thought he wanted it, but now worries about being stuck with it if it doesn't work. He's unconcerned that he disappointed voters in what I feel is a morally despicable way, but is very concerned that the feeling of betrayal by Democratic voters might become wide spread. If you report the truth about this little gambit he has waged, to power share in the Senate as long as all stake holders in the deal know, they're in fact reporting to him you're probably not getting invited to this year’s Christmas Party and that will really sting.

I see us entering a dark period with this Governor where his lack of respect for voters comes into clearer view and I fully expect he's capable of creating an enemies list in Albany, NY as preparation for national office and his entry into the Republican Party. Family history aside this Governor is a Republican at heart and I don't mind saying so even if he wants to put a little guy on his enemies list (or as Rick said in Casablanca) his role of honor, I think in 2016 he'll run as a Republican. The Republican Party is going to be looking for a Centrist and by that time he'll bolt, because he'll have completely burnt his bridges with mainstream Democrats after pulling this 'Coalition' stunt and no doubt more will follow over time.

Mike Flynn "Middle Class Mike'

Post your comment